KARMA system on Mopolauta?
Moderator: Moporators
KARMA system on Mopolauta?
What do you think, would be karma system positive or negative feature on lauta?
do you want karma raitings here?
Look here for prior discussion
for those who do not know: Karma system allows users to vote others users posts, which will result in seeing which member has good/bad karma - writes good or crap posts.
This system is not meant to give dislike to posts you don´t agree with, but to posts which are low quality. This works vice versa, not post with matching stance as yours is good, but high quality (or pretty acceptable) posts would be "like" to their author.
Tell opinions.
do you want karma raitings here?
Look here for prior discussion
for those who do not know: Karma system allows users to vote others users posts, which will result in seeing which member has good/bad karma - writes good or crap posts.
This system is not meant to give dislike to posts you don´t agree with, but to posts which are low quality. This works vice versa, not post with matching stance as yours is good, but high quality (or pretty acceptable) posts would be "like" to their author.
Tell opinions.
Last edited by Tigro on 13 Dec 2012, 21:47, edited 2 times in total.
Re: KARMA system on Mopolauta?
And what would the benefits be? I think people don't need ratings to see which users are posting crap and which aren't.
Re: KARMA system on Mopolauta?
I don't need any KARMA to see who's posting crap.
Re: KARMA system on Mopolauta?
karma system is nonsense. not only for lauta, in general.
Re: KARMA system on Mopolauta?
Please check Tigro's link for an explanation of why this might work. It would make it clearer who might need to be banned for a while. "Banned because you got -50 karma this week" instead of "because you post crap". Makes sense?
-
- 39mins club
- Posts: 423
- Joined: 12 May 2009, 15:28
- Location: A "child friendly" neighbourhood;o
Re: KARMA system on Mopolauta?
If everyone who posts crap got banned there wouldent really be alot of posts on here
Re: KARMA system on Mopolauta?
It would work better on a more anonymous community, I'm pretty sure the votes would be biased here. Pawq, Bismuth, Tigro, A.K.B. etc. posting = auto downvote. Is it really that bad situation that everyone is craving for banning of other people?
Re: KARMA system on Mopolauta?
Ecchi wrote:If everyone who posts crap got banned there wouldent really be alot of posts on here
I really don't think so. Many people only post informative and relevant stuff, and most people rarely post crap. But it would be easier to weed out the AKB's and maybe encourage the Louskus to stop spamming altogether. It's just a simple feedback system. Maybe some of us don't realize when our posts are useless?Orcc wrote:It would work better on a more anonymous community, I'm pretty sure the votes would be biased here. Pawq, Bismuth, Tigro, A.K.B. etc. posting = auto downvote.
Lousku wrote:I realized another problem with this idea: bullying. There's a fair amount of bullying in our community, but a karma system might just make it more obviously evil and result in less of it.
Sometimes feels that way, but maybe not.Orcc wrote:Is it really that bad situation that everyone is craving for banning of other people?
Re: KARMA system on Mopolauta?
No, it doesn't. You can't ban anyone for some -50 karma.Lousku wrote:"Banned because you got -50 karma this week" instead of "because you post crap". Makes sense?
Re: KARMA system on Mopolauta?
Huh, why not?Madness wrote:No, it doesn't. You can't ban anyone for some -50 karma.Lousku wrote:"Banned because you got -50 karma this week" instead of "because you post crap". Makes sense?
Re: KARMA system on Mopolauta?
For the same reason that you can't convict a human through a referendum.
Re: KARMA system on Mopolauta?
we need active moderators, not a karma system.
- Grace
- 38mins club
- Posts: 4849
- Joined: 19 Nov 2005, 10:45
- Location: Deep in your Imagination, Twirling your Dreams and Weaving your thoughts.
Re: KARMA system on Mopolauta?
This would hardly work at lauta. Tigro, Pawq, Bis, AKB etc. would get negative karma automatically for every post regardless of the content and people like Svein and Markku would automatically get positive.
Re: KARMA system on Mopolauta?
I'm quoting myself from the other topic
Anyways, another option to this is indeed active and more strict moderating, but obviously it is not happening atm. This karma system would be kind of outsourcing the moderating to the community as a whole. I think this would be a very nice thing to try at least.
Indeed, maybe some of you would be so blind to give all Tigro posts negative karma. But maybe more people would have some kind of a sense to use it, or are you saying everyone's a retard? I hope not. Then people with lots of negative karma could get warnings or not being able to post for a short period.. don't actually know what is possible with that karma mod.Ville_J wrote:That is actually quite an interesting idea and it could work. I'm sure some people would use it wrong way, give negative points to posts they don't agree with or unlike. But maybe more people would give negatives to really really shit posts, and positive to informative ones. Quick googling told me that there is some karma mod for phpbb at least. But who's up for upgrading, I don't know. I wouldn't hold my breath. But I give this suggestion +1.
Anyways, another option to this is indeed active and more strict moderating, but obviously it is not happening atm. This karma system would be kind of outsourcing the moderating to the community as a whole. I think this would be a very nice thing to try at least.
Re: KARMA system on Mopolauta?
I actually think the opposite will happen.Haruhi wrote:This would hardly work at lauta. Tigro, Pawq, Bis, AKB etc. would get negative karma automatically for every post regardless of the content and people like Svein and Markku would automatically get positive.
Re: KARMA system on Mopolauta?
Downvoted.A.K.B. wrote:[...]
Re: KARMA system on Mopolauta?
Upvoted Madness, because he downvoted A.K.B.
Also, downvoted A.K.B.
Also, downvoted A.K.B.
Re: KARMA system on Mopolauta?
Upvoted A.K.B. everyone else downvoted by A.K.B.
Upvote me or you are a poo-pants!
Upvote me or you are a poo-pants!
Re: KARMA system on Mopolauta?
Upvotes for everyone ^_^
Re: KARMA system on Mopolauta?
I'm gonna get downvoted to oblivion, but...
While it could be a somewhat interesting gimmick, I doubt it would actually improve the mopolauta experience.
While it could be a somewhat interesting gimmick, I doubt it would actually improve the mopolauta experience.
- Pingywings
- Kuski
- Posts: 277
- Joined: 29 Jan 2012, 16:10
- Team: singy
- Location: UK
Re: KARMA system on Mopolauta?
i kinda think the upvoting would be great though. sometimes you see a post and kinda want to show your appreciation but that showage doesn't really deserve a reply saying "lol" or "i agree"
Re: KARMA system on Mopolauta?
+1Pingywings wrote:i kinda think the upvoting would be great though. sometimes you see a post and kinda want to show your appreciation but that showage doesn't really deserve a reply saying "lol" or "i agree"
(:D)
Re: KARMA system on Mopolauta?
0 againPingywings wrote:i kinda think the upvoting would be great though. sometimes you see a post and kinda want to show your appreciation but that showage doesn't really deserve a reply saying "lol" or "i agree"
(:D()