Some people were talking about possible new cups in eol chat today, so I thought it would be good to have a discussion about what kinda cup formats people prefer. So that future cup makers can take that into account.
There's the basic 1 level at a time, each level lasting 1 week, for 10 weeks or so.
Then there could be longer or shorter events.
Battle events.
Elimination cup.
Team cup.
Total time cup.
Multiple levels at the same time.
1on1 events.
Another format I've thought about is having 1 event a week but only lasting 3-4 days. So for example from sunday to tuesday and rest of the week nothing untill next event next sunday. You won't get as bored of the level as you might by playing it longer and the cup doesn't take up all your time. There's time to play battles or other stuff rest of the week without feeling like you're handicaping your own chances. On the other hand it may mean some doesn't have time those specific days, worse winner replays and people feeling even more stressed to get a good time.
What do you prefer?
(Edit: No idea why I made this in advertising.)
Future cup formats
Moderator: Moporators
Re: Future cup formats
-8-12 events (end of wcup felt a bit like people got bored and didn't hoyl that much, so I think 15 was too much)Kopaka wrote:Some people were talking about possible new cups in eol chat today, so I thought it would be good to have a discussion about what kinda cup formats people prefer. So that future cup makers can take that into account.
There's the basic 1 level at a time, each level lasting 1 week, for 10 weeks or so.
Then there could be longer or shorter events.
Battle events.
Elimination cup.
Team cup.
Total time cup.
Multiple levels at the same time.
1on1 events.
Another format I've thought about is having 1 event a week but only lasting 3-4 days. So for example from sunday to tuesday and rest of the week nothing untill next event next sunday. You won't get as bored of the level as you might by playing it longer and the cup doesn't take up all your time. There's time to play battles or other stuff rest of the week without feeling like you're handicaping your own chances. On the other hand it may mean some doesn't have time those specific days, worse winner replays and people feeling even more stressed to get a good time.
What do you prefer?
-Each event lasting various durations depending on difficulty and lenght but a minimum of 1 week so that people with weird schedules have time to play.
-And I like the idea of having longer break between events.
-I know it's easier to remember, but what about start/end times not always same day of the week?
-Some events with multiple levels at once
Don't want:
-Battle events, because I wouldn't want to miss some.
-Total time cup, because it makes hoylas useless, unless all levels same lenght and difficulty which is not gonna happen.
-Elimination cup, because I want to play all events.
-1on1 events is a cool concept, sounds like an elimination cup but without the elimination.
How did you expect this concept to work out btw? Not saying it's not gonna work, curious.
-Team cup is an interesting concept, but wouldn't want it to be like WCup, or any normal cup, where only 3 best players of the team count towards the points. I think this system needs revamp. Something like paired people, or any amount of people per team but only best of the team counts. I'd like to see more concepts for a team cup.
Thanks Kopaka for starting this thread, looking forward to see this going live
Re: Future cup formats
- levs that are pretty easy to just finish
- hoyla and multi style levs < 1 min
- 3-4 days events, maybe 2 days for simple levs
- no pies (even in shortcuts)
- can have 1 or 2 unique events that are a bit different (multiple levs, best average time from top10 wins, etc)
A battle cup would be welcome too. Also I'm a weak player from the very bottom of the results table so my opinion isn't really important.
p.s. Maw, quoting a huge post right above yours seems silly to me.
- hoyla and multi style levs < 1 min
- 3-4 days events, maybe 2 days for simple levs
- no pies (even in shortcuts)
- can have 1 or 2 unique events that are a bit different (multiple levs, best average time from top10 wins, etc)
A battle cup would be welcome too. Also I'm a weak player from the very bottom of the results table so my opinion isn't really important.
p.s. Maw, quoting a huge post right above yours seems silly to me.
Re: Future cup formats
Elimination cup or league system is the most fun.
I would not play in any other cup.
I would not play in any other cup.
Re: Future cup formats
I totally loved elimination cup like https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XhWf748Wwrw . First phase where all players play and then top 32 (or top 16 or w/e) go for elimination. This and Banana cup 4 were the best cup I've played. But I'm not rly motivated in playing cups atm... Just sharing my thoughts.
Re: Future cup formats
nice cup, looks like i gave up on teh lev :/
Re: Future cup formats
Elimination cup would be a blast.. Something similar to TEC.
Also if someone hasn't heard yet, I will host a battle cup with ramone in the future, once he gets his computer fixed
Also if someone hasn't heard yet, I will host a battle cup with ramone in the future, once he gets his computer fixed
Rank #1 battler and the champion of BOSS cup
36 club since 02/2024
36 club since 02/2024
Re: Future cup formats
Zero wrote:Elimination cup would be a blast.. Something similar to TEC.
God Bless America